New York Shuts Down Novig Bid For Temporary Restraining Order
Mike Goodpaster Published 17/11/2026
A New York judge rejected an attempt by prediction market site Novig to gain a temporary restraining order to keep its sports-event contracts operating in the state. It was the ruling of a Manhattan federal judge that Novig's sports-event contracts are sports betting. They are not swaps under federal commodities law, as Novig's lawyers claimed. The ruling prevents Novig from operating in New York and skirting state gambling laws. It also prohibits the company from using a TRO to block state enforcement actions.
Novig's operating company, Ludlow Exchange LLC, filed suit against New York Attorney General Letitia James, New York State Gaming Commission Executive Director Robert Williams, Chair Brian O'Dwyer, and the commission's other members in August.
New York judge is harshly critical of Novig
Southern District of New York Court Judge Colleen McMahon didn't pull any punches in issuing her ruling against Novig's bid for a TRO.
"The Court is not required to disregard common sense," McMahon wrote in her ruling, according to reporting by RG.org. "Novig’s sports event contracts are sports betting."
The judge went as far as to cite Novig’s own public statements in support of her ruling. Those include, “Our north star is to be the largest sports betting platform in the world.”
McMahon stated that sporting outcomes are an "event or contingency."
The judge also suggested that what prediction markets are tying to sell in court are semantics. It might be a twist on the system, but in her opinion, it's still betting.
“Novig makes its money, not off the sucker who places a losing bet on a sports event, but by charging two suckers a fee for the privilege of betting against each other on its platform,” Judge McMahon wrote.
Judge also takes issue with Kalshi and the CFTC
While this ruling came down against Novig, Judge McMahon also devoted part of her decision to an August ruling by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in New York. The federal regulator for prediction markets exercised its emergency authority after Kalshi notified it of a market emergency. The CFTC ordered the exchange to ignore a New York court decision and to continue to operate in the state in accordance with the Commodity Exchange Act’s core principles.
"The Kalshi order smacks of a collusive effort between a regulator and regulatee to generate a claim for conflict preemption," Judge McMahon wrote. "The Court rejects that attempt and notes that the currently effective regulation, implemented pursuant to the special rule, prohibits the listing of event contracts that relate to gaming."
"As such, if the Court were to defer to the CFTC, under the CFTC's own regulations, Novig's listing of these [sports-event] contracts is unlawful."
Judge McMahon also put no stock in the CFTC's stance that the federal Commodities Exchange Act (CEA) supersedes any state gambling laws.
"While the current CFTC clearly believes that the CEA preempts any application of state gambling laws to sports event contracts, this Court owes no deference to that determination," Judge McMahon wrote.
Next stop for Novig: Ohio
Novig's legal team didn't pause to lick its wounds following the setback in New York. On Monday, the company filed suit in Ohio against the Attorney General and state gaming regulators. This legal action also involves sports-event contracts.
Last month, Ohio sent cease-and-desist orders to 10 prediction market sites operating in the state.
Along with the standard federal law vs. state law argument, this legal action by Novig is also suggesting that new CFTC rules regarding derivative swaps undermine the Sixth Circuit Court’s ruling against prediction markets. They are also arguing that the state's actions violate the Dormant Commerce Clause.