Senate Committee Grills CFTC Nominees Over Prediction Markets
Mike Goodpaster Published 18/11/2026
Senate Agriculture Committee lawmakers grilled President Donald Trump's Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) nominees over hot-button issues involving prediction markets. Nominees Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick faced questions about regulating prediction markets and sports betting. The nominees did not address their views on the agency's regulation of sports betting in any specific rulemaking. However, they did acknowledge there is pressure on the agency to clarify the line between regulated event contracts and illegal gambling.
In ongoing legal battles between the CFTC, prediction markets, and state attorneys general and gaming commissions, the CFTC has claimed regulatory control over prediction market event contracts. However, courts often side with the states in rulings on this matter.
Senate committee lawmakers are tough on CFTC hopefuls
The two CFTC nominees set to join Chair Michael Selig are bipartisan nominees put forth by President Trump. Matthew Rowland is the Democratic Party pick. The choice of the Republican Party is Nathan Anonick.
Currently, Anonick is counsel to John Boozman, the chairman of the Senate Agriculture Committee. Rowland was seconded to the Agriculture Committee from the CFTC, where he worked as an attorney.
The biggest question they were facing from the Senate Agriculture Committee was answering how they viewed the debate over whether sports-event contract offerings from CFTC-regulated prediction market sites. Are they or are they not sports betting?
Some lawmakers putting the question to the nominees admitted that they had already made up their minds on the matter.
"I actually do think the law is quite clear that jurisdiction over sports gambling rests in the hands of states and also with tribes — and yet prediction markets continue to operate, I believe in violation of these state and tribal laws," said Sen. Tina Smith, a Democrat from Minnesota.
Nominees seek to dodge the key issue
As they were put under scrutiny by the Senators serving on the Agriculture Committee, the potential nominees were proving adept at ducking and dodging the issue when pressed for an answer on the key prediction market question.
When pressed, Rowland opted for deflection. He cited Regulation 40.11. This measure was adopted by the CFTC in 2011. It prohibits registered exchanges from listing or accepting for clearing certain event contracts involving gaming, terrorism, war, and assassination.
"It's hard for me to comment on the active litigation that the CFTC is engaged in, but I'm certainly very sympathetic to the concerns that the states and tribes have raised and would want to work with them further if I were confirmed on that," Rowland said, according to reporting by The Block.
Anonick described the prediction market event contract debate as a "very charged emotional issue."
Smith wasn't about to hear that excuse.
"I would just argue that, friendly pushback, that I don't think that this is an emotional issue," Smith said. "I think this is a legal issue."
Both nominees indicated that if confirmed, they would listen to industry stakeholders before forming an opinion on prediction market concerns.
CFTC has taken heat for its slowness in filing commission positions
The Senate Agriculture Committee will vote on whether to approve each nominee. Next, a full Senate vote would be required following further hearings before either nominee would be confirmed to their positions with the CFTC.
If they are granted confirmation, Anonick and Rowland would join CFTC Chairman Selig on the CFTC commission. The CFTC and its sister agency, the Securities and Exchange Commission, have taken heat over the failure of these organizations to fill all five commissioner seats with bipartisan representation.